  A disappointed John Irving fan, 2009-01-28
I've read pretty much all of John Irving's books, with Owen Meany and Garp being among my favourite books of all time. After hearing very mixed reviews about Setting Free the Bears, I avoided it for a long time, but finally thought I'd give it a go.
To set the scene, I'm the type of reader who perseveres with books and has only ever abandoned a handful of books. Unfortunately, this was one of those books that after 100ish pages I just couldn't continue with. I didn't enjoy his writing style this time, which was very different to any of his other books, and the depth of characters which I loved in Owen Meany and Garp simply wasn't there. This combination made an unlikely plot impossible to engage with.
Overall my advice would be to avoid Setting Free the Bears, particularly if you are a fan of his other great works.
setting free the bears, 2005-07-19
an earlier outing from john irving possibly my favourite writer ever. a good yarn as you might expect from the man who wrote the cider house rules,garp, a prayer for owen meany and countless other classics but without the hook of a truly brilliant character to both detest and love as you do with his other books.
for newcomers i wouldnt reccomend this. go with the world according to garp, cider house rules or a prayer for owen meany. there is no real urgency to the story.
for those who came to this book for further antics of the kind got up to by earl the bear in the hotel new hampshire, you won't find them, which is not to say that this isnt delightful just not priority reading where irving is concerned
Don't let the bears loose!, 2009-11-04
This book was an early selection by the Round the World Book Group in Edinburgh. It is not a work of literature with beautiful writing to discuss, or with great characterisation. It simply tells a simple story. It is not the best book by John Irving which I have read. I would say - only read this one if you are an Irving fan, or if you are a completist.
breathtaking, 2002-08-16
This is an incredible, beautiful book, as so many of Irving's are. What sets this apart from his other work is the raw energy that cuts through it. There is an amazing vitality that I haven't seen in other Irving titles (and I've read them all and loved almost all) and it swept me away. Ok, so it doesn't have the overwhelming impact of Meany, or the breadth of his later work, but it crackles with energy, and his use of language is both electifying and lyrical. It reads like a young and brilliant author enjoying himself. To my mind, it is Water Method Man that really reads like a first novel - like a writer trying to establish himself by being contrivedly deep and introverted.If you like his later work, or indeed any of his work, I'd recommend this wholeheartedly.
A good start, 2008-04-30
I read this a long time ago, and picked it up off the shelf again in anticipation of a trip to Vienna later this week. I had good memories of the style of this first novel by Irving, and the account of two friends on a road trip through Austria which opens up into memories of the Anschluss and Siggy's family history has held up well. This long central section, which is bookended by the account of the journey away from and back to Vienna, is probably my favourite part; historical events, accidents and incidents are described in terms of their effect on family members and other individuals, many of whom perished in capricious circumstances. This is movingly echoed in the statement which Irving quotes from the Serbian general Drazha Mihailovich at his trial after the war: "I wanted much, I started much, but the gales of the world have carried away both me and my work." It's a poignant image, which was also memorably used in Ian Fleming's Casino Royale.
|
